So to summarize:
In the Northern Hemisphere
Touches the Atlantic Ocean
Surrounds at least one island under the control of a European country
Does not border Europe
Does not border South America (i.e., not the Caribbean Sea)
Not the Labrador Sea or the Greenland Sea
Is it the Sargasso Sea? I...
Until I played one of the Carmen games from 1995 with Lynn Thigpen, and I found a note left behind from one of her agents, I didn't realize that Carmen pays her people too Lol